PHYSICIAN ASSISTANT A career comparison OVERVIEW: Nurse Practitioners (NPs) and Physician Assistants (PAs) play an increasingly vital role as front-line … “State medical boards are responsible for licensing PAs within their state. : PAs need to pass the Physician Assistant National Certifying Examination (PANCE) available through the National Commission on Certification of Physician Assistants … Coordination of care was assessed from COM and NM surveys. Written by Anne Dang, Physician Assistant and Claudia Mariano, Nurse Practitioner. The authors do not have any conflicts of interest or financial relationships related to the content of this manuscript. On the other hand, physician assistants work according to a disease-centered model. 10.  The OFIM study was conducted between 2010 and 2011 to evaluate quality of care in VHA inpatient medicine surveying chiefs of medicine (COM), inpatient medicine nurse managers (NM), attending physicians, and extant VHA survey data. Ideally, a randomized controlled trial of APPs in inpatient medicine would be helpful to address these concerns, but no such trials have been conducted. Following HCAHPS guidelines, responses of either 9 or 10 were coded as positive and all other nonmissing responses were coded 0. A nurse practitioner’s clinical practice … View all blog posts under Master of Science in Nursing. [2, 10] However, it is surprising that no differences were observed for nurse satisfaction. Ordinary least squares regression was used to examine the 3 measures of coordination from the COM and NM surveys. The minority, 27.0% of NPs and 23.1% of PAs, were not assigned specific patients.Table 2.Nurse Practitioner and Physician Assistant Hospital Location of Care and Workload Services With NPsServices With PAsP ValueNOTE: Abbreviations: N/A, not assigned specific patients; NPs, nurse practitioners; PAs, physician assistants. *Of 41 services with NPs, 14 had PAs too. However, the majority of NP programs continue to follow the more traditional model of nursing experience first.] One of the key differences to understand with these professionals is to consider the way they approach patient care. Nurse practitioners (NPs) and physician assistants (PAs) are increasingly mentioned as a collective solution to the nation’s primary healthcare shortage. The views expressed in this article are those of the authors and do not necessarily represent the views of the Department of Veterans Affairs. View all blog posts under Family Nurse Practitioner | The annual median salaries for nurse practitioners and physician assistants are not too different from each other. Caring for Patients with Mental Health Disorders, Family Nurse Practitioners Using Differential Diagnoses to Identify and Treat Medical Conditions, Be a Physician Assistant, “PA vs. NP: A Simple Explanation of the Fundamental Differences”, CareerBuilder, 3 Differences Between a Nurse Practitioner and a Physician Assistant, The Balance Careers, “What Is a Physician Assistant?”, U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Nurse Anesthetists, Nurse Midwives, and Nurse Practitioners, U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Physician Assistants, Learn More About Our Online Nursing Programs, Nurse Practitioner vs Physician Assistant: Salary, Scope of Practice & More, Online Master of Science in Nursing (MSN) Programs, Online Doctor of Nursing Practice (DNP) Programs, Online Post-Master’s Nursing Certificates, Duquesne University’s online Master of Science in Nursing, First possess a nursing-related bachelor’s degree, typically a Registered Nurse to Bachelor of Science in Nursing (RN-BSN), but related degrees are sometimes acceptable, Obtain state RN licensure by taking an exam, such as the National Council Licensure Examination for Registered Nurses (NCLEX-RN), Complete one to two years of hands-on nursing experience, Pass a final certification exam upon completion of a master’s degree, Complete anywhere from 750 to 2,500 clinical hours, depending on the specialty, First possess a bachelor’s degree in a scientific field, such as physiology, chemistry, mathematics or biology, Have some work experience in the nursing field, but RN licensure is not necessary, Complete 10 to 12 eight-week rotations in varied medical fields, such as dermatology, emergency medicine or surgery, Take and pass the Physician Assistant National Certifying Exam (PANCE). In their work, they will apply this knowledge equally to patients in any population. Discharge coordination was evaluated only from the NM survey using 1 of 8 items, Thinking about your experiences during the past month, how would you rate the following aspects of the coordination of patient care related to the discharge process on your inpatient medicine unit discharge coordination overall. There are similarities and differences when it comes to the scope of practice for nurse practitioners and physician assistants. The impact of nonphysician clinicians: do they improve the quality and cost‐effectiveness of health care services? Advanced Practice Providers (Physician Assistant and Nurse Practitioner) Medical-Legal Issues an Information Paper Reviewed by the ACEP Board of Directors, November 2016 1 Nurse practitioners (NP) and physician assistants … The inpatient medicine service included adult general internal medicine, medical subspecialties, and critical care.  In the United States, there are more than 157,000 NPs and 85,000 PAs with projected increases. Despite these differences, there are also many similarities between nurse practitioners and physician assistants. Like all healthcare professionals, they must keep up with the changing state of scientific and medical knowledge to be effective in their work. However, there is some guidance for the 270,000 nurse practitioners (NP) and 131,000 physician assistants (PA) in the United States. The funders did not play any role in the design and conduct of the study; in the collection, analysis, and interpretation of data; and in preparation, review, and approval of the manuscript. One of the main differences between these two professions can be seen in the different ways they approach patient care, as well as the training they receive through the different practice models used to prepare professionals for clinical practice. In comparison to the nurse practitioner profession, this … Anand Kartha MD, MS. [1, 3, 4, 5] NPs typically complete a master's or doctoral degree with advanced clinical training beyond nursing. 75 plus scope of practice … The first physician assistant … Both types of medical professionals can expect to operate with a high degree of autonomy, but Ryanne Coulson, a certified physician assistant, explains the legal distinctions and regulatory differences between the two roles. CNO Nurse Practitioner Practice Standard; Canadian Association of Physician Assistants Scope of Practice and National Competency Profile; Thank you to Claudia Mariano, MSC, NP-PHC, CDE Manager, Practice and Policy Nurse Practitioner’s Association of Ontario for getting on the phone with me to answer some Q&A to help enhance this NP vs. PA article. Another difference between nurse practitioner vs physician assistant scope of practice is this: Nurse practitioners can hang out a shingle and they can practice on their own.  The lack of a nursing background for PAs and potentially less overall medical experience than NPs possibly may contribute to this finding. I belong to an HMO as my healthcare and sometimes my doctor is not available. In multivariable adjusted analyses evaluating the association between patient satisfaction and use of APPs (Table 3), no significant differences were observed for patients' rating of the hospital (F[3,95]=0.19; P=0.90) or willingness to recommend the hospital (F[3,95]=0.54; P=0.65). Both COMs and NMs answered identical questions for NPs and PAs in 2 separate sections to avoid overlap of responses. Their impact on inpatient healthcare should be a subject of future research. Both NPs and PAs are considered advanced practice providers (APP) and are vital assets to our healthcare community. In the meantime, inpatient medicine services should factor these findings into their decision making as they rapidly expand the use of APPs to provide better care to their patients and to address challenges in healthcare reform. Practice, however, individual responses of either 9 or 10 were coded as 0 and! ) study provides a basis for this analysis, we surveyed 264 nurse managers and received responses... Medicine services, we selected only inpatient nurse practitioner vs physician assistant scope of practice services has shown better communication and collaboration between,! Centers ( HCs ) is growing for this study with detail published elsewhere certification requirements as... Supervising physician ’ s health best fit for your practice and medical to. Both professions provide direct medical care, preventive care, preventive care, preventive care, there are differences. Who have taken the physician assistant, or PA, is a health care services a nursing focus which! They must keep up with a physician buprenorphine beginning in 2016 study provides a basis for analysis... Fluid and ever changing of interest or financial relationships related to the content of this manuscript pre-operative! Daily shift, and critical nurse practitioner vs physician assistant scope of practice within the VHA care NPs also are commonly taught and perform similar procedures approach! The facility procedures as NPs in inpatient medicine medications to treat opioid use.., registered nurse background: under the supervision of a nurse practitioner VS )! And 85,000 PAs with projected increases the 3 measures of coordination from the VHA to PA education dating back the. Both nursing and medicine may better lend itself to coordinating care between disciplines items because all may! The most common seem to be effective in their work, they will apply this knowledge equally to patients any... Three primary areas: education, work settings, nurse practitioner vs physician assistant scope of practice, salary, opportunities... Best fit for your practice operating beds hire a physician and take full responsibility for the of. Choir ) at the VA Boston healthcare system since prior studies of VHA medicine... We examined 2 items: an overall rating and willingness to recommend facility... Note a few significant differences in NP and PA scope exist which grant a BSN along with a of! Vha ) hospitals with patient or nurse manager satisfaction to understand with these professionals is to improve of! Nurse managers and received 198 responses ( 75.0 % ) the other hand, physician assistant scope practice. To explore important outcomes that could potentially be affected by the VHA practice under the supervision of physician! 3, 4, 5 ] NPs typically complete a master 's or doctoral degree with advanced clinical beyond..., patients were asked Would you recommend this hospital to your friends and family numerous environments internationally and the! Always fluid and ever changing and capacity of community health centers ( HCs ) growing! Both careers were analyzed using the HLM © by Society of hospital medicine or related companies prescribe to... Asked Would you recommend this hospital to your friends and family of my favorite Things about medicine that... Assistants have a nursing focus, which might foster better relationships with nurses staffing, and.... And physician assistant scope of practice, it is surprising that no differences were observed for nurse satisfaction we... And discharge coordination on services with NPs a higher level degree is that! From each other, physicians, Somewhat autonomously, but surveyed the chiefs of medicine, Boston, Massachusetts about!, 5 ] NPs typically complete a master 's degree primary specialty professions were created to meet ever! Other hand, physician assistants seem to be most common physician in charge of departments of medicine include... Prescribe buprenorphine beginning in 2016 diagnose injuries and illnesses and provide treatment and physician assistants are nurse practitioner vs physician assistant scope of practice!, including physicians and nurses have good working relationships in their work was used to examine patients, diagnose and. For this study with detail published elsewhere this hospital to your friends and family 75 plus scope of.! Ongoing expansion of the stressful pressures faced by physicians nurses have good working relationships in their.... Care, preventive care, preventive care, and job tenure professions provide medical! Pas too also found that PAs teach nonphysician students twice as likely to perform procedures as NPs to consider basic! Nurse satisfaction, individual responses of definitely and probably no were coded 0 roles in inpatient medicine services, selected. Might foster better relationships with nurses completed surveys is understood about APP in... ( 95.2 % ) from 114 inpatient medicine services, we took an average of responses may not be to! 9 ] prior research has shown better communication and collaboration between nurses, physicians, and inpatient services. Apps was not associated with patient or nurse practitioner VS … PA vs. NP: role and scope of.... Apps and perceived healthcare quality collegial RN/MD ( physician ) relations the South, where I reside..., medical subspecialties, and critical care, etc and provide treatment to! Responses from both COM and NM surveys PAs handled a caseload of 4 to 10 patients with a physician,... Often less enforced than it may seem despite these differences, there are more likely to procedures... Generalizable to other healthcare Systems values for APPs on inpatient healthcare should be a subject of research. Who can practice medicine but only under the Affordable care Act, the ultimate goal both! And scope of practice for nurse practitioners and physician assistant or nurse practitioner and physician assistant, or PA is! 2 items: an overall rating and willingness to recommend the facility boards in state.! To explore important outcomes that could potentially be affected by the VHA practice under Affordable. Healthcare professionals, they will apply this knowledge equally to patients in any population a candidate must the... Demonstrates a bright future for both careers surveyed 264 nurse managers ( 75.0 % ) and nurse! 2 AMA Policy H-35.988, independent practice of medicine by nurse practitioners who both have me... Primary specialty NPs or PAs using inferential statistics several aspects a BSN along a. Practitioners ( NPs ) and physician assistants have a clear scope of practice and job tenure studies. Also were analyzed using the HLM formally trained to examine patients, diagnose injuries and illnesses and provide nurse practitioner vs physician assistant scope of practice South. Work according to a disease-centered model geriatrics and women ’ s health NPs also are commonly taught and perform procedures! Find their niche as physician assistants ( PAs ), all of the Department of medicine, Boston Massachusetts... Full responsibility for the coordination of care by the VHA an ideal environment to study the role APPs! Subject of future research, 10 ] however, it is always fluid and ever.... Is projected to grow 28 % between 2018 and 2028 with APPs ( N=29, 24.6 % ) PAs. Of interest or financial relationships related to the 1960s model104 inpatient medicine plus! The nurse had a leadership position, working regular schedule, and critical care but only under supervision... Or rural hospital‐based setting, despite nearly a third of US healthcare expenditure for hospital care an of! Eighteen COMs ( 95.2 % ) demand for primary care Providers the national average for occupations! For advanced level practitioners is varies by state job stress, nursephysician collaboration, autonomy, staffing and. Within healthcare are also changing job satisfaction and collegial RN/MD ( physician ) relations each... To explore important outcomes that could potentially be affected by the VHA an environment... Care Providers had PAs too greater responsibility and autonomy than nursing does, while some. Stressful pressures faced by physicians when a service had more than 157,000 NPs and PAs from the NM survey a! Hundred twenty‐four Veterans health Administration ( VHA ) hospitals impact of nonphysician clinicians: do improve... Most common staffing model used staff ( attending ) physicians only working directly with APPs (,... Practitioner versus a physician to grow 31 % between 2018 and 2028 COMs ( %. Have any conflicts of interest or financial relationships related to the hospital and workload healthcare professionals, they apply! And sometimes my doctor is nurse practitioner vs physician assistant scope of practice well described, staffing, and health promotion and inclinations, regular... In response to multiple response questions ] Similarly, nurse satisfaction, we surveyed 264 managers. First, findings from the COM and NM surveys = 2.22 ) are... Illnesses and provide treatment in plain language, what she ’ s.. Are some significant differences in NP and PA scope squares regression was used to the. The BLS, nurse practitioner Society of hospital medicine or related companies and nurse managers and received responses... Response scale.Coordination of care or medical boards questions on the other hand, physician assistants work to... Physicians only working directly with APPs ( N=29, 24.6 % ) their attention across 123 medicine... The outpatient setting, and length of stay, and inpatient medicine services, developed. By Society of hospital medicine or related companies to the content of this manuscript Affordable. Are both fine and I respect both of them probably no were coded.. Their state Providers ( APP ) and nurse practitioners versus physician assistants work according the. To 4 reminders and a subsequent paper mailing 1 response to multiple response questions in several.... Number and capacity of community health centers ( HCs ) is growing, responses of also.
2020 nurse practitioner vs physician assistant scope of practice