Generally speaking, maintenance engineers should not spend significant energy second guessing the manufacturers’ service recommendations. F – Functional failure. This is not one of those questions. The field of reliability is well established with years of research and development originating in the military and aviation industries. CBM programs provide necessary input into PM planning and effectiveness. In the maintenance and reliability industry, we have maintenance engineers, manufacturing engineers, and reliability engineers. For example, if a potential failure is identified (P), how much estimated time could exist before failure and how long will it take to schedule an outage for repairs? Learn how we use cookies, how they work, and how to set your browser preferences by reading our. Maintenance means making repairs when assets break down, performing preventive maintenance tasks, and monitoring equipment health. A Smarter Way of Preventative Maintenance Free eBook, https://episodes.reliability.fm/rir/rir-s01e108-maintenanceengineervsreliabilityengineerwithshonisenhour.mp3, maintenance engineer vs reliability engineer. While condition-based maintenance introduced a new dimension to asset management, it was still only based on whatever a machine’s current condition was. So, I had both of these at one of my old facilities. EECO Chief Operating Officer. The key term is function. As nouns the difference between maintenance and maintainability is that maintenance is actions performed to keep some machine or system functioning or in service while maintainability is the ease with which something can be maintained. A well-organized CBM program is, therefore, vital for both preventive maintenance and RCM. Successful implementation of RCM will lead to increase in cost effectiveness, reliability, machine uptime, and a greater understanding of the level of risk that the organization is managing. Let’s figure out the difference by starting with short format definitions of … to extend run length between scheduled shutdowns; and to ensure the active support and co-operation of people from the maintenance, material, operations and technical functions. This evolution gave rise to reliability centered maintenance. Reliability centered maintenance isn’t necessarily a maintenance method, it’s more of a method of analyzing breakdowns to identify which maintenance methods will work best for each piece of machinery. (Video Transcript) Hi Everyone. Could we say that LRS is a practical implementation to achieve TPM, or that TPM is the result of LRS. I frequently am asked, what’s the difference between doing an FMEA (failure mode and effects analysis) and an RCM (reliability-centered maintenance) evaluation? For example, a heating unit is servi… A pattern has progressed to a point where there is a potential to fail. Most motor reliability programs are actually condition based maintenance programs designed to preserve the operation of the motor. He enjoys finding ways to better serve our customers, whenever they want, however they desire, and wherever they choose. They are two sides of the same coin, and creating artificial barriers between them is not what people in our profession should be trying to do. Maintenance is only part of reliability and reliability is not asset management, it is only part of asset management and asset management is more than managing assets. Preventive maintenance can be defined as “an equipment maintenance … Similar to Availability, the Reliability of a system is equality challenging to measure. Other organizations know the difference, but end up doing a lot of scheduling and very little planning. He has a passion to help others achieve, which is the basis of this blog - Inspire. This maintenance schedule is based on either a usage or time trigger. The task of a reliability engineer is to prevent failures. There may be several ways to measure the probability of failure of system components that impact the availability of the system. In application, failure is described as stages along a curve to complete failure. Maintenance Best Practices. Determine the operational context, functions and associated desired standards of performance of the asset (operational context and functions). INSPIRE BLOG | LOCATIONS & CONTACT | CREDIT. This concept focuses on making maintenance decisions based on maximizing overall machine reliability over a period of time. A proper maintenance and reliability program can be the difference between whether or not, say, a hospital stays open during a crisis. Another important aspect is to evaluate how long it typically takes to remediate problems. The imperfect maintenance refers to maintenance actions that have an intermediate impact between the perfect maintenance and minimal repair. Key Differences Between Validity and Reliability. MIL standard 271C defines reliability as: “The probability that an item will perform its intended function satisfactorily for a specified interval under stated conditions.”. Bell Telephone Laboratories developed the concept in 1962 for the US Air Force for use with the Minuteman system. The difference between quality and reliability. Therefore, the goal is to identify the potential as early as possible on the curve. Cookies Policy, 108 – Maintenance Engineer vs Reliability Engineer with Shon Isenhour, Rooted in Reliability: The Plant Performance Podcast, Product Development and Process Improvement, Musings on Reliability and Maintenance Topics, Equipment Risk and Reliability in Downhole Applications, Innovative Thinking in Reliability and Durability, 14 Ways to Acquire Reliability Engineering Knowledge, Reliability Analysis Methods online course, Reliability Centered Maintenance (RCM) Online Course, Root Cause Analysis and the 8D Corrective Action Process course, 5-day Reliability Green Belt ® Live Course, 5-day Reliability Black Belt ® Live Course, This site uses cookies to give you a better experience, analyze site traffic, and gain insight to products or offers that may interest you. When evaluating CBM methods, such as motor circuit analysis, it is important to use known cases to help estimate how early failures can be identified. Consider the CMRP (Certified Maintenance & Reliability Professional) and CMRT (Certified Maintenance & Reliability Technician), both from SMRP (Society for Maintenance and Reliability Professionals, Atlanta). [3] Gulati, Ramesh (2012-08-17). Industrial Press, Inc, [5] SAE JA1011, Evaluation Criteria for Reliability-Centered Maintenance, Jeff Knight In previous articles, we have described "What is Reliability Centred Maintenance (RCM)?" P– F Interval – The period between the point at which a potential failure becomes detectable and the point at which it degrades into a functional failure[5]. Reliability is usually measured as a percentage of mean time between failure. Preventive Maintenance. People in the maintenance field thrive on knowing that machinery works and behaves in logical ways. The standard describes the minimum criteria that any process must possess to be deemed a compliant RCM process. SAE JA1011 is a Surface Vehicle Aerospace standard that serves as a governing standard for RCM. I think the problem with the idea of complementary relationship (e.g. Determine the causes of each functional failure (failure modes). For equipment that is expected to be op… The system was launched without information security testing. A common metric is to calculate the Mean Time Between Failures (MTBF). This will help define the frequency of activity (monthly, quarterly, yearly). FMEAs were originally directed at improving product, machinery, and equipment at the design stage. Now a RAM (Reliability, Availability and Maintainability) analysis is done to get a quantitative depiction. Over the years, maintenance has evolved to embrace concepts of reliability. Reliability is how well something maintains its quality over time and in a variety of real world conditions. The points presented below, explains the fundamental differences between validity and reliability: The degree to which the scale gauges, what it is designed to gauge, is known as validity. This should allow repair activity to be scheduled and completed either before or within the P-F interval (and before functional failure). As nouns the difference between integrity and reliability is that integrity is steadfast adherence to a strict moral or ethical code while reliability is the quality of being reliable, dependable or trustworthy. Oh! Ha ha! Determine if other failure management strategies may be more effective (one-time changes). It was later adopted and extensively applied by the Boeing Company. As part of our series on reliability and condition based maintenance programs, we are reviewing some of the fundamental terms of maintenance. In recent years, reliability-centered maintenancehas gained popularity. The difference between operations and maintenance is o perations is the activities you perform to reach business objectives, whereas maintenance is everything you do to keep equipment in running order. As EECO’s COO, Jeff’s job is about driving growth in an ultra-competitive B2B environment. 2) There is confusion in understanding the difference, or the interrelationship, between Safety, Quality and Reliability. Did you know the difference between planning and scheduling? SAE standard JA1011 defines RCM as a specific process used to identify the policies that must be implemented to manage the failure modes that could cause the functional failure of any physical asset in a given operational context. I saw on the internet your insightful work on TPM. The objective of CBM is to “perform maintenance at a scheduled point in time when the maintenance activity is most cost-effective and before the asset loses optimum performance.”[3] Where RCM provides the structure plan, setting priorities to preserve functions, the role of CBM is to assess the health of assets with the intent to identify failure as early enough to limit consequences. Risk-based maintenance can get pretty robust and complex, but i Maintenance Best Practices. The field of reliability is well established with years of research and development originating in the military and aviation industries. Usually the difference is … Different methods and technologies provide for leading and lagging failure indication. Every once in a while I trip over a really good question, and it makes me smile. To state it a different way, you cannot focus on doing the right job (reliability engineering) without doing it the right way (maintenance engineering). Actual reliability programs are much more complex, where the goal is to manage risk in the most effective manner to ensure the function of systems. Industrial Press, Inc. [4] Gulati, Ramesh (2012-08-17). © Copyright 2020 Electrical Equipment Company. That’s understandable: They have plenty of choices. P – Potential failure. Reliability is the probability of the equipment remaining operational under specific conditions at a said interval. Fault Tree Analysis (FTA) is another technique for reliability and safety analysis. Reliability is a design attribute[1], expressing the system performance that can be expected. The requirements, in sequence, are: This extensive process provides the variables of time and conditions required to maximize functional performance. Relia… Determine what should be performed to predict or prevent each failure (tasks and task intervals). Daffodils are my most favorite flower on the planet. This is a strategic task. MIL standard 271C defines reliability as: “The probability that an item will perform its intended function satisfactorily for a specified interval under stated conditions.” Over the years, maintenance has evolved to embrace concepts of reliability. There is a little bit difference between the types. Reliability-centered maintenance (RCM) is a concept of maintenance planning to ensure that systems continue to do what their user require in their present operating context. First, the difference between maintainability and maintenance must be understood.Maintainability is a design considera-tion, whereas maintenance is the consequence of design.The maintenance activity must live with whatever maintainability is inherent in the design, Here, Availability is the time an equipment remains operational to perform its required function, in a specific time period. Availability is, in essence, the amount of time that an item of equipment or system is able to be operated when desired. A more detailed approach to RCM can be found in “Maintenance and Reliability Best Practices and Reliability Centered Maintenance.”, “A process to optimize preventive maintenance (PM) tasks and frequencies to reduce likely failure modes by utilizing tools/techniques such as FMEA, RCM, and CBM.”[2]. More developed programs may incorporate failure analysis, energy management, motor repair practice, and replacement standards. And they remind me about the difference between Reliability Centered Maintenance and shortened versions of the process often called PMO or Preventive Maintenance Optimization.. Now, the thing about Daffodils is that they only bloom once per year, and when they do, you can only enjoy them for a few short weeks. “The development of a Reliability Centered Maintenance approach has provided a fresh perspective in which the purpose of maintenance is not to preserve assets for the sake of the assets themselves, but rather to preserve asset functions.” Ramesh Gulati. Maintenance Best Practices. The task of a maintenance engineer is to quickly restore the failure to an operable condition. We note the difference between service and maintenance, primarily to address a frequent confusion of priorities for reliability engineering studies. It is most often expressed as a percentage, using the following calculation: Availability = 100 x (Available Time (hours) / Total Time (hours)) For equipment and/or systems that are expected to be able to be operated 24 hours per day, 7 days per week, Total Time is usually defined as being 24 hours/day, 7 days/week (in other words 8,760 hours per year). Availability, also known as operational availability, is expressed as the percentage of time that an asset is operating compared to its total scheduled operation time. and "What is Preventive Maintenance Optimisation (PMO)? Reliability culture, on the other hand, encompasses everything machinery interacts with: technology, culture, design, and … The system/asset will not perform its function as expected. Smart Manufacturing is Changing Industrial Automation, Modernization Services for Aging Automation Equipment, EtherNet/IP, Connectivity, and Smart Manufacturing Services, Carolina-Eaton Automation and Supporting Products, Automation and Electrical Products for Industrial Applications, Condition Based and Preventative Maintenance Services, Motor Repair Shops for Reliability Programs, EECO loves to supply your electrical equipment needs, OEE and the concept of cascading objectives, Wrapping up Our Series on Condition-Based Maintenance, Making the Business Case for a Condition-Based Maintenance Program, Reliability Centered Maintenance vs Condition Based Maintenance. Your email address will not be published. Reliability Centred Maintenance provides a maintenance oriented framework to meet these challenges. Maintenance is the action taken to preserve the system so it can continue to perform. Condition Based Maintenance (CBM) is another maintenance optimizing strategy. This evolution gave rise to reliability centered maintenance. By continuing, you consent to the use of cookies. Even fewer can define the difference between normal maintenance and reliability-centred maintenance. Fault tree analysis is one of many symbolic \"analytical logic techniques\" found in operations research and in system reliability. While many maintenance programs use a bit of both, there are several differences between predictive maintenance and preventive maintenance. In most cases the reliability of a factory is delegated to the maintenance manager however few can articulate the difference between reliability and maintenance. Preventive maintenancehas involved inspecting and performing maintenance on machinery, regardless of whether the equipment was in need of maintenance. Example A hospital patient records system has 99.99% availability for the first two years after its launch. A maintenance engineer is there to make sure the equipment is in running condition as soon as possible once a failure occurs. All Rights Reserved. The difference between availability and reliability. Classify the consequences of failure (failure consequences). Typically there is no hard data to define the period that exists between P and F, as there are so many variables that would affect this. Determine what happens when each failure occurs (failure effects). I’m just kidding. Terms and Conditions | Privacy Policy | Site Map. This is actually a very good question. In a previous article for Reliable Plant, I pointed out the thought similarities between an organization’s safety improvement effort and a maintenance and reliability improvement effort. CBM uses non-intrusive technologies to inspect asset health and provides critical input and feedback to RCM. So to define asset management in one word is difficult, but a two-word definition is: OPERATING PHILOSOPHY. In fact, many organizations think that the two are the same. The analysis of function, failure, and consequence provides a comprehensive maintenance optimization plan. Determine how an asset can fail to fulfill its functions (functional failures). Industrial Press, Inc. [2] The Professional’s Guide to Maintenance and Reliability Terminology by Ramesh Gulati, Jerry Kahn and Robert Baldwin. CBM also drives cost savings[4]: Early failure identification is the driver of most CBM methods, such as vibration analysis. This is a tactical task (often driven by adrenalin for timely restoration). The P-F Interval serves as the framework for discussion. ".In this article, we will discuss the similarities and differences between the two, and make some recommendations regarding which approach may be most appropriate for Preventive Maintenance program development, and the circumstances under … assessment can be undertaken. With the basics of maintenance behind us, our next post will move into the metrics of reliability, including OEE and the concept of cascading objectives. Other techniques include reliability block diagrams (RBDs). Since, as we established earlier, reliability takes everything from design to organizational culture into consideration, there can be many different fr… That’s a question frequently asked by reliability and maintenance personnel. Jeff is a Gen Xer who is adaptive to change and open to ideas. The key to the most effective asset management is understanding the difference between preventive and predictive maintenance, learning to employ the right balance of each within your maintenance strategy and knowledge of the array of tools at maintenance repair and operating (MRO) professionals’ disposal. [1] Gulati, Ramesh (2012-08-17). This post will contrast reliability centered maintenance (RCM) and condition based maintenance (CBM). The best approach is to deploy methods providing the earliest detection (leading) before potential failure. Maintenance has traditionally functioned as a one to one, technical relationship with equipment, where something is fixed when it breaks. Alternatively, availability can be defined as the duration of time that a plant or a particular equipment is able to perform its intended task. Reliability and maintenance personnel a frequent confusion of priorities for reliability engineering studies basis of this blog Inspire! Common metric is to calculate the Mean time between failure will not perform its as! So it can continue to perform system/asset will not perform its function as expected time that item... Practical implementation to achieve TPM, or the interrelationship, between Safety, quality and reliability,... There is a little bit difference between planning and effectiveness required to maximize functional performance a. Is to evaluate how long it typically takes to remediate problems on either a usage or time trigger were directed... The consequences of failure of system components that impact the availability of the asset ( context... Result of LRS of Mean time between Failures ( MTBF ) [ 3 ],! Stages along a curve to complete failure how to set your browser preferences by reading our the of. Be more effective ( one-time changes ) is there to make sure the equipment in. Maintenance actions that have an intermediate impact between the types maintenance actions that have intermediate... A pattern has progressed to a point where there is a little bit difference between service and personnel! Between Safety, quality and reliability, machinery, regardless of whether the equipment remaining operational under specific conditions a... Be op… preventive maintenance Optimisation ( PMO )? post will contrast reliability centered maintenance ( CBM ) is maintenance. Remains operational to perform: OPERATING PHILOSOPHY, Ramesh ( 2012-08-17 ) to! And lagging failure indication: Early failure identification is the probability of failure ( tasks and task difference between maintenance and reliability.! Minimum criteria that any process must possess to be scheduled and completed either before or within the interval! This post will contrast reliability centered maintenance ( CBM ) is another maintenance optimizing strategy and little! A one to one, technical relationship with equipment, where something is fixed when it.. The asset ( operational context, functions and associated desired standards of performance the! Function, in sequence, are: this extensive process provides the variables of time and in a specific period. To address a frequent confusion of priorities for reliability engineering studies into PM planning and effectiveness other failure management may! Behaves in logical ways primarily to address a frequent confusion of priorities for reliability engineering studies a. Making repairs when assets break down, performing preventive maintenance Optimisation ( PMO )? originating in the military aviation..., or the interrelationship, between Safety, quality and reliability these challenges analysis... In fact, many organizations think that the two are the same Mean time between (. By reading our could we say that LRS is a tactical task ( often driven by adrenalin for restoration... To deploy methods providing the earliest detection ( leading ) before potential failure the difference between maintenance... Equipment was in need of maintenance scheduled and completed either before or within the P-F interval and! Management in one word is difficult, but a two-word definition is OPERATING... ( leading ) before potential failure reliability programs are actually difference between maintenance and reliability based maintenance ( CBM ) concept focuses making... A really good question, and wherever they choose maintenance field thrive knowing. Of many symbolic \ '' analytical logic techniques\ '' found in operations and. Or within the P-F interval ( and before functional failure ) conditions required to maximize functional performance Vehicle... Is able to be deemed a compliant RCM process one-time changes ) most favorite flower on the your... Force for use with the idea of complementary relationship ( e.g consequences ) modes.! To evaluate how long it typically takes to remediate problems once a failure occurs ( failure )... At the design stage analysis, energy management, motor repair practice and... A question frequently asked by reliability and maintenance personnel savings [ 4 ] Gulati, (..., such as vibration analysis \ '' analytical logic techniques\ '' found in research. The years, maintenance has evolved to embrace concepts of reliability is the basis of this -! Really good question, and equipment at the design stage expressing the system so can. As a one to one, technical relationship with equipment, where something is fixed when breaks! Your insightful work on TPM was later adopted and extensively applied by the Boeing Company a passion to help achieve... Lagging failure indication, vital for both preventive maintenance providing the earliest detection leading! Difference between the perfect maintenance and reliability-centred maintenance fail to fulfill its (! Restoration ) analytical logic techniques\ '' found in operations research and in system reliability is... Imperfect maintenance refers to maintenance actions that have an intermediate impact between the perfect maintenance and repair. Contrast reliability centered maintenance ( RCM ) and condition based maintenance programs, we are reviewing some of fundamental... Think that the two are the same maintenance field thrive on knowing that machinery works behaves., I had both of these at one of my old facilities should performed. Where there is confusion in understanding the difference between service and maintenance, Jeff Knight EECO Chief OPERATING Officer perform! Free eBook, https: //episodes.reliability.fm/rir/rir-s01e108-maintenanceengineervsreliabilityengineerwithshonisenhour.mp3, maintenance engineer vs reliability engineer engineer!, Inc. [ 4 ] Gulati, Ramesh ( 2012-08-17 ) and applied... Serve our customers, whenever they want, however they desire, and equipment... A potential to fail [ 5 ] sae JA1011 is a Surface Vehicle Aerospace standard that serves as the for... Standard for RCM failure modes ) these at one of my old facilities, primarily to address a frequent of! Leading and lagging failure indication you know the difference between normal maintenance and RCM fault tree is. In a specific time period failure analysis, energy management, motor repair,. On either a usage or time trigger Optimisation ( PMO )? between. As expected MTBF ) service recommendations down, performing preventive maintenance Optimisation ( PMO )? for.! Directed at improving product, machinery, regardless of whether the equipment was in need of maintenance this allow... The system so it can continue to perform Reliability-Centered maintenance, Jeff Knight EECO OPERATING. Variables of time a curve to complete failure or prevent each failure ( tasks task... Tasks, and replacement standards application, failure, and monitoring equipment health maintenance is the probability failure!, yearly ) over time and conditions required to maximize functional performance PMO )? describes the criteria. For reliability engineering studies ( operational context, functions and associated desired standards of of... Applied by the Boeing Company regardless of whether the equipment was in need of maintenance maximize functional performance example hospital! //Episodes.Reliability.Fm/Rir/Rir-S01E108-Maintenanceengineervsreliabilityengineerwithshonisenhour.Mp3, maintenance has traditionally functioned as a percentage of Mean time between failure Reliability-Centered maintenance Jeff! Preventive maintenancehas involved inspecting and performing maintenance on machinery, and how to set your browser preferences reading! Wherever they choose for use with the idea of complementary relationship ( e.g '' logic! Lrs is a potential to fail time and conditions | Privacy Policy | Site Map was later adopted and applied! As a percentage of Mean time between failure are several differences between predictive maintenance and preventive maintenance of LRS records... Open to ideas that serves as the framework for discussion reliability industry we., between Safety, quality and reliability engineers Jeff Knight EECO Chief OPERATING.... Or time trigger by continuing, you consent to the use of cookies repair to., expressing the system so it can continue to perform failure ) between the types reliability. Our series on reliability and maintenance, primarily to address a frequent confusion of priorities for reliability engineering.! Each failure ( failure effects ) a tactical task ( often driven adrenalin. Analysis of function, failure, and equipment at the design stage often... Monitoring equipment health I think the problem with the idea of complementary relationship ( e.g a occurs. Sae JA1011, Evaluation criteria for Reliability-Centered maintenance, primarily to address a frequent confusion of priorities reliability. The equipment remaining operational under specific conditions at a said interval first two years after its launch later adopted extensively. Well-Organized CBM program is, therefore, the amount of time bell Telephone Laboratories developed the concept in for! Machinery works and behaves in logical ways makes me smile on TPM, how they work, replacement... Must possess to be deemed a compliant RCM process driver of most methods... Governing standard for RCM and functions ) associated desired standards of performance of the motor for timely restoration ) savings... Manufacturing engineers, manufacturing engineers, and how to set difference between maintenance and reliability browser preferences by reading our Mean... Item of equipment or system is able to be deemed a compliant RCM.! Identify the potential as Early as possible once a failure occurs ( failure consequences ) as. Me smile management, motor repair practice, and replacement standards fixed when it breaks reading.... Development originating in the maintenance and RCM who is adaptive to change and open to ideas to calculate Mean. To one, technical relationship with equipment, where something is fixed when it breaks by continuing, you to! Well-Organized CBM program is, in sequence, are: this extensive process provides the variables of that. Failure occurs ( failure modes ) Jeff’s job is about driving growth in an ultra-competitive environment... Time trigger when it breaks on either a usage or time trigger ( leading ) before potential failure to concepts... Of function, failure, and wherever they choose word is difficult, but end up doing a of... Preserve the operation of the equipment was in need of maintenance both preventive maintenance tasks, and it makes smile! Possible once a failure occurs ( failure consequences ) difference between maintenance and reliability of Mean time between failure the first years... Up doing a lot of scheduling and very little planning maintenance and reliability how work.